A mate of mine sold his investment property in 2019 and tipped the lot into an ETF. He told me at the time that property was “dead money” and shares were the future. Fast forward to today, and he is back asking me about property again. Not because shares did badly (they didn’t), but because he realised something most people miss: the way you build wealth through property is fundamentally different to shares, and comparing the two on headline returns alone is like comparing a marathon to a sprint.
I get it. The property vs shares debate in Australia is one of those conversations that never goes away. And with the 2026 federal budget shaking up negative gearing rules for established properties, the question has become even more loaded. So let me walk you through what actually matters when you are deciding where to put your money, and where most people come unstuck with this comparison.
Why the Property vs Shares Debate Misses the Point
Every year, someone publishes a chart showing that the ASX 200 returned X% and property returned Y%, and declares a winner. The problem? Those comparisons almost never account for how borrowing changes the picture.
Over the past 20 years, Australian residential property has delivered around 7.7% annual growth on average. The ASX 200, including dividends reinvested, has returned roughly 8% per annum over the same period. On the surface, shares win. Barely.
But nobody buys an investment property with 100% of their own cash. Most investors put down a 10% to 20% deposit and borrow the rest. That means a 7.7% increase in the value of a $600,000 property is not 7.7% on your money. It is 7.7% on $600,000, which is $46,200 in growth, against your $60,000 to $120,000 deposit. That is a return on your actual capital of anywhere from 38% to 77%.
You simply cannot replicate that with shares unless you are borrowing on margin, which carries significantly more risk because a margin call can force you to sell at exactly the wrong time. This is the core of the property vs shares comparison that most articles gloss over.
The logic is fairly straightforward. Property lets you control a large asset with a relatively small amount of your own money, and the bank is comfortable lending you 80% or more because the underlying asset is a physical dwelling that people need to live in.
Property vs Shares in Australia After the 2026 Budget
The 2026 federal budget changed the landscape for property investors, and it is worth understanding exactly what shifted.
From 1 July 2027, if you buy an established residential property, any net rental losses will be quarantined. That means you can no longer offset those losses against your salary or other income in the year they occur. Instead, those losses get carried forward and can only be offset against future residential rental income or capital gains from residential property.
This is a meaningful change. For years, negative gearing on established properties was one of the key tax advantages that made property attractive compared to shares. That advantage has now been narrowed for new purchases of established dwellings.
However, there are a few things worth noting. If you already own investment properties, nothing changes. Your existing arrangements are grandfathered. And if you buy a newly built property, negative gearing still applies in full. The government specifically designed the change to push investment towards new housing supply.
For shares, the tax treatment has not changed. Borrowing to invest in income-producing assets like shares remains fully deductible. Franking credits still flow through. So on a purely tax-adjusted basis, shares have become relatively more attractive for certain investors, particularly those who were relying on negative gearing losses to reduce their tax bill.
But tax is only one part of the equation. And I have seen too many people make investment decisions based purely on tax outcomes, only to realise years later that they optimised for the wrong thing.
The Property vs Shares Leverage Advantage That Investors Rarely Explain Well
I mentioned this earlier, but it deserves its own section because it is the single biggest reason property has created more millionaires in Australia than any other asset class.
Here is what most people get wrong. They look at property returns and share returns side by side and conclude that shares are “just as good” or “slightly better.” But they are comparing an unleveraged return to a leveraged one, or worse, comparing a leveraged property return to an unleveraged share return without acknowledging the structural difference.
Let me put some rough numbers on it. Say you have $100,000 to invest.
With shares, you buy $100,000 worth of an ASX 200 index fund. Over 10 years, at an average return of 8% per annum (including dividends reinvested), your portfolio grows to roughly $215,000. That is $115,000 in gains on your $100,000.
With property, you use that $100,000 as a deposit on a $500,000 investment property. Over 10 years, at an average capital growth of 7% per annum, the property is worth roughly $983,000. That is $483,000 in capital growth. Yes, you still owe the bank around $400,000 (assuming interest-only for simplicity), but your equity has grown from $100,000 to approximately $583,000. And you have been collecting rental income the entire time.
Same starting capital. Wildly different outcomes. That is the power of leverage in a stable, appreciating market.
Now, borrowing works both ways. If property values fall, your losses are amplified too. But Australian residential property has a track record that is hard to argue with: national dwelling values have not experienced a sustained, multi-year decline in the modern era. Short-term corrections happen, but they have always been followed by recovery and growth.
Where Shares Actually Win in the Property vs Shares Equation
I am not here to tell you property is always better. That would not be honest, and it would not be useful.
Shares win on accessibility. You can start investing in an ASX ETF with as little as $500. Property requires a deposit of $60,000 to $200,000 or more, depending on the market, plus stamp duty, legal fees, and a cash buffer. If you are early in your career and do not have the capital for a deposit, shares are a sensible way to start building wealth while you save.
Shares win on liquidity. You can sell your shares on Monday and have the cash in your account by Wednesday. Selling a property takes weeks or months, and it costs you in agent fees, marketing, and potentially capital gains tax. If you need access to your money quickly, shares give you that flexibility.
Shares win on diversification with small amounts. With $10,000 in an ETF, you own a slice of 200 or more companies across multiple sectors. With $10,000 in property, you own nothing, because $10,000 does not buy you a property. You need a much larger sum to get started, and when you do, you are concentrated in a single asset in a single location.
And after the 2026 budget, shares have a relative tax advantage for new investors who would have been negatively gearing established property. The ability to deduct borrowing costs against your income remains intact for share investments, while it has been restricted for new established property purchases.
Why Property Still Wins for Most Australians Building Long-Term Wealth
Despite everything I just said about shares, I still believe property is the stronger wealth-building vehicle for most Australians. And I have seen this play out dozens of times with clients across my career.
Here is why.
Forced savings. A mortgage forces you to make repayments every month. That discipline is built into the structure. With shares, there is nothing stopping you from selling when the market drops 15% and you panic. And most people do exactly that. The behavioural finance research is clear: the average investor underperforms the market because they buy high and sell low. Property’s illiquidity is actually a feature, not a bug, because it stops you from making emotional decisions.
Borrowing power at low cost. As I covered above, banks will lend you 80% to 90% of a property’s value at relatively low interest rates. Try getting a bank to lend you 80% of a share portfolio. It does not happen, and if it does, the rates and margin requirements are punishing.
Rental income covers your costs. A well-chosen investment property in the right location will generate rental income that covers a significant portion (and sometimes all) of your holding costs. That means someone else is effectively paying down your asset while it appreciates. Dividends from shares serve a similar purpose, but you cannot amplify them with borrowed capital the same way.
You can add value. With property, you can renovate, develop, or subdivide to manufacture equity. You cannot ring up BHP and ask them to add a bedroom to increase the share price.
Tax advantages still exist. Even with the 2026 changes, property depreciation remains available, new builds still qualify for full negative gearing, and the 50% CGT discount applies to properties held for more than 12 months. Property remains one of the most tax-effective asset classes in Australia when structured correctly.
Property vs Shares: It Is Not Actually Either/Or
The smartest investors I work with do not pick one. They use both.
The typical pattern I see with successful clients looks something like this: they start by building a share portfolio while they save a deposit. Once they have enough, they buy their first investment property. Over the next few years, they use the equity growth in that property to fund a second purchase, and then a third. Along the way, they continue contributing to their share portfolio through superannuation or a separate brokerage account.
By the time they are 10 to 15 years into this approach, they have a diversified portfolio across both asset classes, with property providing the growth amplified by borrowing, and shares providing liquidity and diversification.
Where folks get caught off guard is when they treat this as a binary choice. “Should I invest in property or shares?” is the wrong question. The right question is: “Given where I am financially right now, which asset class should I focus on next, and how do they fit together?”
If you have $50,000 in savings, limited borrowing capacity, and are five years into your career, shares might be the right starting point. If you have $150,000 in equity, a solid income, and a clear strategy for your first or second investment property, property is likely where you will build the most wealth in the shortest time.
What the 2026 Budget Means for Your Next Move
To be honest with you, the negative gearing changes have spooked some investors who probably should not be spooked. The fundamentals of property investment have not changed. People still need somewhere to live. Rental vacancy rates across Australia are sitting at historically low levels. Population growth is outpacing new housing supply. And capital growth in well-chosen locations continues to outperform broader market averages.
What has changed is the tax efficiency of buying established property with the intention of running it at a loss. If that was your entire strategy, then yes, you need to rethink your approach. But if you are buying investment-grade property in the right locations, with strong rental demand and genuine capital growth fundamentals, the numbers still work.
For investors who are open to new builds, the playing field is actually more favourable than before. You still get full negative gearing, you get higher depreciation deductions, and you are investing in an asset that the government is actively incentivising.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is property or shares a better investment in Australia in 2026?
Neither is universally better. Property offers superior returns through leverage, where a small deposit controls a large asset, and has historically created more household wealth in Australia. Shares offer accessibility, liquidity, and diversification with smaller amounts. After the 2026 budget changes, shares have a slight tax advantage for investors who would have negatively geared established property, but property’s leverage advantage remains significant.
How did the 2026 budget change negative gearing for property investors?
From 1 July 2027, net rental losses on established residential properties purchased after Budget night (12 May 2026) will be quarantined. This means losses can only be offset against other residential rental income or residential property capital gains, not against salary or other income. Existing investment properties are grandfathered, and newly built properties still qualify for full negative gearing.
Can I still build wealth through property after the negative gearing changes?
Absolutely. The negative gearing changes affect one specific tax benefit for established property. Property’s core wealth-building advantages, including leverage, rental income, capital growth, depreciation deductions, and the 50% CGT discount, remain intact. Investors focusing on new builds or positively geared established properties are largely unaffected.
Should I invest in shares while saving for a property deposit?
This is a common and often sensible approach. Investing in a diversified ETF while you build your deposit allows your money to grow rather than sitting in a savings account. Just be mindful of your investment horizon. If you plan to buy a property within two to three years, keeping your deposit in a high-interest savings account may be safer, as share markets can be volatile over short periods.
Key Takeaways: Property vs Shares in Australia
- Property’s leverage advantage is the single biggest differentiator: a 10% to 20% deposit controls a large appreciating asset, amplifying returns on your actual capital by a factor of five to ten.
- The 2026 budget changes quarantine negative gearing losses on newly purchased established properties from 1 July 2027, but existing holdings are grandfathered and new builds remain fully eligible.
- Shares win on accessibility, liquidity, and diversification with smaller amounts, making them ideal for early-stage investors or those building a deposit.
- Property’s built-in discipline (mortgage repayments, illiquidity) protects investors from the emotional buy-high-sell-low behaviour that erodes share returns for most individuals.
- The strongest wealth-building approach combines both asset classes: shares for liquidity and diversification, property for leveraged long-term growth.
- Tax should inform your structure, not dictate your strategy. Choosing an asset class purely for a tax deduction is one of the most common and costly mistakes Australian investors make.
Property vs Shares in Australia: Final Thoughts
The property vs shares debate will keep going, and honestly, it should. Both are legitimate wealth-building tools, and both have earned their place in a well-constructed portfolio.
But if you are asking me, as someone who has spent over 13 years working with property investors and helped build a community of more than 78,000 people, where the biggest wealth outcomes consistently come from, it is property. Not because the headline returns are always higher. But because leverage, forced savings, rental income, and the ability to add value create a compounding effect that shares simply cannot match for most people.
The 2026 budget changes are real, and they matter. But they have not fundamentally broken the property investment model. They have shifted some of the rules around established property, and that means investors need to be smarter about what they buy, where they buy it, and how they structure the purchase. That is always been the case, though. The investors who do well in property are the ones who treat it as a strategy, not a gamble.
If you are sitting on the fence, trying to figure out whether property or shares is the right next step for you, the answer depends on your specific situation: your income, your equity, your borrowing capacity, your timeline, and your goals. That is exactly the kind of conversation we have in a discovery call.




